• Home
  • Best of Lists
  • Reviews
  • DC Restaurants
    • NE
    • NW
    • SE
    • SW
  • MD Restaurants
  • VA Restaurants
  • Ask Rick
  • Home »
  • Best of Lists »
  • Reviews »
  • DC Restaurants »
    • NE »
    • NW »
    • SE »
    • SW »
  • MD Restaurants »
  • VA Restaurants »
  • Ask Rick »
 
 
Rick Eats DC A website devoted to eating in DC
  • Recent Articles & Reviews

    • These Are a Few of My Not-So-Favorite Things
    • Celebrating an Icon and Other Good Eats at Hanumanh
    • Queen’s English Still Reigns
    • Branching Out at Imperfecto and Joy
    • Tom Sietsema Dropped Stars From His Restaurant Reviews; I’m Adding Them to Mine
  • Archives

    • March 2023
    • January 2023
    • December 2022
    • October 2022
    • August 2022
    • December 2021
    • October 2021
    • September 2021
    • August 2021
    • July 2021
    • December 2020
    • October 2020
    • September 2020
    • August 2020
    • June 2020
    • May 2020
    • February 2020
    • January 2020
    • November 2019
    • October 2019
    • September 2019
    • August 2019
    • July 2019
    • June 2019
    • May 2019
    • February 2019
    • January 2019
    • December 2018
    • November 2018
    • October 2018
    • September 2018
    • August 2018
    • July 2018
    • June 2018
    • May 2018
    • April 2018
    • March 2018
    • February 2018
    • January 2018
    • December 2017
    • November 2017
    • October 2017
    • September 2017
    • August 2017
    • July 2017
    • June 2017
    • May 2017
    • April 2017
    • March 2017
    • February 2017
    • January 2017
    • December 2016
    • November 2016
    • October 2016
    • September 2016
    • August 2016
  • Categories

    • Articles
    • Best Burgers
    • Best of Lists
    • Best Pizza
    • Cheap Eats
    • Featured
    • NE
    • NW
    • Restaurants DC
    • Restaurants MD
    • Restaurants VA
    • SE
    • SW
    • Uncategorized


Don't Miss a Thing
Enter your email address:*
Please enter all required fields
Correct invalid entries
Powered by FeedBlitz
Please choose a color:

Tom Sietsema Dropped Stars From His Restaurant Reviews; I’m Adding Them to Mine

Posted by Rick Chessen

 

You may have seen that Tom Sietsema, the longtime Washington Post food critic, recently decided to permanently end the awarding of stars. His column explaining his decision made a powerful case, just not the one he was trying to make. He didn’t convince me that he did the right thing by dropping ratings from his reviews; he convinced me that I needed to add them to mine.

Let’s start with why ratings are a good thing. People like them and use them. Indeed, before he explains why he’s dumping them, Tom notes that he originally used them to give readers “an immediate take on a restaurant.” That’s still true. Most people have lives that only occasionally involve thinking about restaurants (I know, go figure). They use ratings to triage their time — why read the gory details of a 1-star review from a reviewer they trust? More likely they’ll do what I do with movies: flip through the Weekend section and stop to read the three or four star reviews (or sometimes two-star reviews) that catch my eye. But if Ann Hornaday declared tomorrow that she’s no longer awarding stars, my reaction wouldn’t be to buckle down and read every movie review. Instead, I’d ask my wife if she wanted the Weekend section because I wasn’t going to look at it.

So why is Tom ditching the stars? No good reason.

First, Tom reports that he can count on one hand the number of readers who have told him they want the stars back. He claims many more, including chefs, have told him that the lack of stars encourages them to read more of his columns. I assume that Jeff Bezos did not sign off on the who-happens-to-reach-out-to-me methodology of consumer research. It’s hardly surprising that most people who approach someone like Tom Sietsema are fans who want to say something nice. But the real tell is that he notes chefs like the lack of stars. You would think that chefs would not be top-of-mind when a restaurant critic is thinking about his audience. The truth is that most DMV residents don’t even know who the Post’s restaurant critic is — and only a sliver of those are tracking his internal tsuris about stars. The goal should be making it easier for the broader public to find good restaurants, not to cater to the cognoscenti.

Second, Tom insists that the 1-4 star scoring system didn’t work very well. He says there’s not enough room to reflect nuance with just four stars, even with half-stars added to the equation. But even if that’s true, it’s an issue with the particular system and not ratings per se. If four stars lack nuance, why not move to a numerical scale from 1-100? The potential for nuance would be 10x. Tom acknowledges that someone suggested a numbered system “but her idea sounded complicated.” Maybe Tom’s friend also invented the scoring system for Olympic figure-skating. Then I take Tom’s point. But Rotten Tomatoes uses a 1-100 scale and I’ve never heard anyone complain that it’s just too difficult to wrap their head around.

Third, Tom claims that “reading the full review” is the best way for readers to assess whether the restaurant is right for them. Ok, sure. People should read the full review. They should also floss twice a day and read the position papers of everyone running for school board before entering the voting booth. But they won’t, so now what? I think you cut people some slack and find ways to give them as much information as possible. Granted, folks who read the full restaurant review may make more informed choices than those who just looks at the rating. But it’s an imperfect world. Don’t let perfection be the enemy of someone finding a good Thai restaurant in Arlington.

Fourth, Tom proclaims that “given all the industry’s challenges, restaurants merit more than a symbol to sum them up.” That sounds more like a pandering applause line from someone running to head the National Restaurant Association than a serious argument. Even Prince had a symbol to sum himself up. And if restaurants deserve more than a symbol in these uncertain times, why not movies, TV shows, and wine-making? They’re all popular activities with an artistic component that seem to be able to live with ratings of one sort or another without falling into some kind of puffing self-regard.

Finally, Tom likens himself to Chef Aaron Silverman of Pineapple & Pearls, who told Tom he wanted to take the fine dining model and “smash [it] to the ground.” The concluding line of Tom’s piece is “If chefs can smash things to the ground, so can critics.” Um, sorry to break it to you, Tom, but ditching stars isn’t re-inventing the genre. As far as I can tell, the reviews themselves are exactly the same. And I see you still include information on things like decibel levels and Covid protocols. Which is all terrific, but let’s not pretend that dropping stars makes you some kind of rule-breaking rebel.

Listen, I get it. Tom is the Big Dog. He’s the main restaurant critic for the Washington-freakin’-Post. He obviously gave a lot of thought to this and he’s not going to reverse himself. And why should he? He’s probably hearing nothing but praise from friends and industry insiders for his courage in expunging the crassness of ratings. But that’s what makes this so frustrating. Because he’s so powerful, his decision matters. It will result in fewer people reading about restaurants because it increases the cost of admission. That’s a huge bummer. And while there’s nothing my little blog can do to offset that, I’m going to add a rating system anyway (probably on a 1-10 scale with decimal points, but open to suggestions). I should have done something like this long ago, but, frankly, I hadn’t thought through how the lack of ratings made my blog less accessible. Now I have. And I’m not being sarcastic when I thank Tom for pointing the way.

This entry was posted in Articles, Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.
← Previous Post Next Post →

2 Responses to Tom Sietsema Dropped Stars From His Restaurant Reviews; I’m Adding Them to Mine

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*



Don't Miss a Thing
Enter your email address:*
Please enter all required fields
Correct invalid entries
Powered by FeedBlitz
Please choose a color:
  • Home
  • Best of Lists
  • Reviews
  • About this site
  • About Rick
  • Contact
  • DC Visitors
  • DC Restaurants
  • MD Restaurants
  • VA Restaurants

Website by MightyLittleWebShop.com